Fanatical Cashback: Every Portal's Rate, Compared

The best Fanatical cashback we found is 7% at BeFrugal, read from BeFrugal's own Fanatical page.

Fanatical cash back rates by portal

Every rate below was read from that portal's own Fanatical page, and every row shows when we last looked. Where a rate has a catch, the catch is printed next to the number rather than underneath it.

PortalRateLast checked
BeFrugal
Hoopla Doopla
RebatesMe
Up to 7%A maximum, not a standing rate. RebatesMe's category table for this store goes as low as 3%.source
ShopBack
Extrabux
2.5%source
MaxRebates
1.8%source
GoCashBack
Mr. Rebates
TopCashback
3%This is a maximum, not a standing rate. The everyday rate is usually lower.source
CouponFollow
Rate not publishedThis portal lists the merchant but did not show a rate we could read. That is different from paying nothing.source
Price.com
Rate not publishedThis portal lists the merchant but did not show a rate we could read. That is different from paying nothing.source
RetailMeNot
Rate not publishedThis portal lists the merchant but did not show a rate we could read. That is different from paying nothing.source
Active Junky
Not carriedThis portal does not cover this merchant.
chirpyest
Not carriedThis portal does not cover this merchant.
Fluz
Not carriedThis portal does not cover this merchant.
Lolli
Not carriedThis portal does not cover this merchant.
MyPoints
Not carriedThis portal does not cover this merchant.
Raise
Not carriedThis portal does not cover this merchant.
Rakuten
Not carriedThis portal does not cover this merchant.
Sunshine Rewards
Not carriedThis portal does not cover this merchant.

Rates move without notice, so treat anything more than a couple of days old as worth re-checking at the portal before you shop.

How to get Fanatical cashback, step by step

  1. Open BeFrugal's Fanatical page and click through to Fanatical from there. That click is what ties the order to your account, so start every Fanatical order this way rather than from a bookmark or a search result. The rate as we last read it was 7%.
  2. Shop in that same tab and session. Don't leave for a coupon site and come back, and turn off any other cashback or coupon extension before you check out: the last click before the order is the one that gets credited, and another extension's click can take it.
  3. Check out in one go, using only codes BeFrugal itself shows for Fanatical. A code from somewhere else can void the cashback on many stores.
  4. Wait for it to confirm. Verified cash back sits in the account for 30 to 90 days, set by the retailer's return policy and its payment cycle with BeFrugal. Store pages say cash back is typically available for payment 15 to 60 days after purchase. Returning part of the order, or cancelling it, changes what gets paid.
  5. Get paid. BeFrugal pays by: Check, PayPal, direct deposit, Venmo, Zelle or an eGift card. Check and direct deposit are US only. Minimum: $0.01 for PayPal or direct deposit; $25 for a check. Timing: On request. Most payouts are sent on the next business day after the request.

Getting paid, portal by portal

Each portal's own help pages, as written there. The source link on each row goes to the page it came from. These are the portal's terms, not Fanatical's.

PortalPaid byMinimumConfirmation window
BeFrugalsourceCheck, PayPal, direct deposit, Venmo, Zelle or an eGift card. Check and direct deposit are US only.$0.01 for PayPal or direct deposit; $25 for a check.Verified cash back sits in the account for 30 to 90 days, set by the retailer's return policy and its payment cycle with BeFrugal. Store pages say cash back is typically available for payment 15 to 60 days after purchase.
Hoopla DooplasourceCheck, Venmo or PayPal.$5.00 in approved cash back per period, for PayPal, Venmo and paper checks alike. A balance under that carries over to the next period.Usually posts within 10 days of purchase, then becomes yours after 90 days.
RebatesMesourcePayPal, credit card, Alipay, check or gift cards.$10 in available cash back, not counting bonuses.Cash back becomes available after the 90-day return window.
ShopBacksourcePayPal or a US bank account via ACH, once the balance clears the minimum.$5 of Confirmed Cashback on ShopBack's payment-methods and clear-time guides; its withdraw how-to says $10.Pending within 48 hours of checkout, then Confirmed once the partner store's claim time has been fulfilled: usually a few weeks for retail, after trip completion for travel.
ExtrabuxsourcePayPal, eGift cards, ACH bank deposit (US only), check (US only), or a donation to a charity.$10 available balance, with at least one confirmed purchase carrying more than $1 in available cash back.Usually tracked within 1 to 7 days of purchase, then held through a 90-day window for returns or cancellations at most stores before it becomes available.
MaxRebatessourceCheck or PayPal, in US dollars, and sometimes other options such as a donation to charity.$10.00 per payment, with a $2,000.00 maximum.Pending for 90 days to cover store return policies, cancellations and commission collection; it often takes up to 90 days for cash back to become payable, depending on the product and the merchant.
GoCashBacksourcePayPal, check, gift card (US only) or Helipay.$10 in withdrawable cash back, not counting sign-up, referral or activity bonuses for the first withdrawal.It can take up to 120 days for cash back to become available.
Mr. RebatessourceA rebate check by mail, or payment via PayPal, Venmo or an Amazon gift card.$10 in Available Rebates.Rebates post to Pending within 1 to 3 business days of the order or ship date, then stay Pending for 90 days from the posting date before moving to Available.
TopCashbacksourceBank transfer, Venmo, PayPal, gift cards, a Virtual Visa Prepaid Card or an American Express Virtual Reward Card.None for PayPal, Venmo or bank transfer; some gift cards have one.No fixed window. Cash back goes pending, then confirmed once the retailer reviews the order, then payable once the retailer's network is invoiced. TopCashback prints an estimated payout speed on each merchant's page.
CouponFollowsourcePayPal; a valid US PayPal account has to be connected to CouponFollow.An Available Balance of at least $10.Pending for up to 60 days, to ensure a purchase isn't returned or refunded.
Price.comsourceDebit card deposit, PayPal, Venmo, Zelle, gift cards, a donation to charity, or crypto.$10 per withdrawal, with a $500 cap per withdrawal and per day.Typically 30 to 90 days: pending until the retailer confirms the purchase and its return period ends.
RetailMeNotsourcePayPal or Venmo, from the RetailMeNot account.A minimum approved balance of $5.01 is required for a redemption.In about 45 days the cash back lands in the RetailMeNot account as redeemable.

Fanatical cashback rate history

Only changes are listed. Re-confirmations are not noise worth showing.

  1. Mr. Rebates1%
  2. Mr. Rebatesrate no longer published
  3. Price.comrate no longer published
  4. Price.com2.4%
  5. Rakutenmerchant dropped by this portal
  6. CouponFollowrate no longer published
  7. ShopBack3%
  8. Raisemerchant dropped by this portal
  9. Price.comrate no longer published
  10. TopCashback3%
  11. Lollimerchant dropped by this portal
  12. GoCashBack1%
  13. Active Junkymerchant dropped by this portal
  14. Sunshine Rewardsmerchant dropped by this portal
  15. Extrabux2.5%
  16. RebatesMeUp to 7%
  17. BeFrugal7%
  18. Fluzmerchant dropped by this portal
  19. MaxRebates1.8%
  20. RetailMeNotrate no longer published
  21. MyPointsmerchant dropped by this portal
  22. chirpyestmerchant dropped by this portal
  23. Hoopla Doopla4%
  24. Mr. Rebates1%
  25. ShopBackrate no longer published

How these Fanatical numbers were produced

Fanatical cashback FAQ

Which portal pays the most for Fanatical cashback right now?

BeFrugal, at 7%. That's the rate a returning shopper gets, which is how the table ranks: an "up to" ceiling or a new-customer rate never takes this spot over a lower rate everyone gets.

How long does Fanatical cashback take to pay out?

On a click-through portal there are two waits, one after the other: the portal has to confirm the order with Fanatical, which mostly tracks Fanatical's return window, and then the confirmed balance has to be paid out, which is the portal's own rule. Buying Fanatical's gift card through a portal skips the first wait: that cashback is paid when the card is bought.

Is there a minimum payout?